top of page

Is the Shroud a Forgery?

Difficulty of Counterfeiting the Shroud

  • Many of the features of the Shroud mentioned in this compendium would not be known to a painter or forger 500+ years before the technology to discover those features.

  • The knowledge of physiology was very limited at the time when a forger putatively faked the Shroud’s 3-d image and physiologically detailed blood wounds. 

  • There simply is no sign of residue, pigments, chemicals, … in the linen.  Only the discoloration of oxidized dehydrated cellulose in surface fibers of the flax threads.  

  • Any liquid would have wicked deeper, penetrating into the fibers. 

  • In theory, a few details could have been faked by a very knowledgeable and careful forger in the 13th century: such as the microscopic pollen and limestone dust from around Jerusalem and Constantinople.  However, it seems very unlikely that a forger would have known to do all that and to actually have gone to the trouble to do so. 

  • Would any 13th century forger even consider that such details would become detectable centuries later when microscopes were invented, and when chemical compositions could be analyzed? 

A 13th Century Crucifixion?

  • Actually crucifying a victim would surely be the only way a forger could get the physiological details correct regarding the blood and serum stains. 

  • Otherwise, simply daubbing blood on the Shroud would be tricky: if too fresh it might wick widely like on bandages on wounds but unlike on the Shroud. 

  • Or, if the blood were too coagulated, it would not leave the marks similar to those on the Shroud.  This is the opinion of a number of physicians and the result of actual experimentation. 

  • A forger would have great difficulty registering the daubed-on blood stains with a faked image to the precision evident on the Shroud.

 

§Next §Previous §Subtopics §References

ParentsTalk.

Subscribe for ParentsTalk Updates!

Thanks for submitting!

© 2023 by Parents Talk

Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page